A 12,000-Square-Foot Masterpiece on Over 31 Acres with 470 Feet of Private Shoreline Now Listed for Sale
LAKE GEORGE, N.Y. — One of the distinguished private estates in the northeastern United States is now available on the market. The Evaley, a 12,000-square-foot Tudor Revival residence situated on 31.29 manicured acres with 470 feet of private shoreline, is listed for $23,500,000. Listed by Jordan March, Real Estate Agent for SERHANT. and star of Netflix’s Owning Manhattan, the offering presents an opportunity to own a legacy estate on the shores of the iconic Lake George.
Located on the region’s renowned Millionaires’ Row, The Evaley was designed and built between 1912 and 1913 by financier Charles Jones Peabody, brother to philanthropist George Foster Peabody. Architectural details include a granite and stucco façade, half-timber framing, and elegant gambrel dormers. Inside, the estate showcases exquisite chestnut paneling, leaded-glass windows, original pocket doors, intricate crown molding, and six fireplaces, spread across eight bedrooms and eight bathrooms.
Photo Courtesy: Matthew Anderson / Anderson Captures
The Evaley is zoned Residential Commercial High Density–Lake Shore (RCH-LS), permitting up to three units per acre. This offers unique flexibility for creating a private multi-generational compound, a boutique resort, or a wellness retreat with thoughtful architectural and environmental considerations. Few properties in the Northeast combine history, acreage, shoreline, and development potential in such a balanced way.
Beyond its architectural pedigree, The Evaley offers a range of modern luxuries required for a contemporary retreat. Amenities include a finished third floor with dual home offices, a state-of-the-art wine cellar, a game room, and garage space for ten vehicles. The estate was strategically sited to maximize panoramic views of Lake George and the Adirondack Mountains. Each morning begins with sunrise over the water from the lakefront veranda, while evenings conclude with moonlight reflecting across the lake from the primary suite’s balcony.
Photo Courtesy: Matthew Anderson / Anderson Captures
A defining feature of The Evaley is its direct access to yachting. With private dock and mooring capabilities, the estate accommodates vessels for leisure cruising, entertaining, and discreet waterfront arrivals. For buyers accustomed to seamless mobility and water-based living, The Evaley offers the opportunity to depart from your private dock and navigate 32 miles of pristine, glacier-fed lake. Whether arriving by yacht, seaplane, or chauffeured motorcade, the estate is equipped to provide seamless transitions and maintain privacy.
Lake George—often referred to as the “Queen of American Lakes”—has long been a destination for presidents, industrialists, and discerning travelers. Its natural beauty, protected shoreline, and clean waters are complemented by proximity to private aviation hubs and world-class recreation. For high-net-worth buyers seeking an inland estate with lakeside ambiance and alpine serenity, Lake George continues to emerge as an exclusive hidden gem.
Photo Courtesy: Matthew Anderson / Anderson Captures
Just minutes from The Evaley, residents will find some of the finest Lake George has to offer. Culinary highlights include elevated dining at Bistro LeRoux, The Log Jam Restaurant, and The Docksider, as well as artisanal coffee and pastries from Caffe Vero and Madeline 1982 Bakery. Wine and spirits enthusiasts can visit the Lake George Distilling Co. or Adirondack Winery. At the same time, year-round recreation includes Million Dollar Beach, Charles R. Wood Park, Cronin’s Golf Resort, Hickory Ski Center, and Berry Pond Preserve. The Lake George Steamboat Company offers scenic cruises directly from the village harbor. This property is also located a short distance from Bolton Landing, Albany, and Saratoga.
The Evaley is zoned Residential Commercial High Density–Lake Shore (RCH-LS), permitting up to three units per acre. This offers flexibility for creating a private multi-generational compound, a boutique resort, or a wellness retreat with architectural and environmental integrity. Few properties in the Northeast combine history, acreage, shoreline, and development potential in such a balanced way.
The listing comes at a time of significant momentum for Jordan March and SERHANT., the innovative brokerage founded by Ryan Serhant. Working alongside them is James Casaccio, broker with Premier Partners LG. The Evaley represents the team’s continued focus on legacy assets, destination properties, and world-class marketing that appeals to today’s global luxury buyer.
